"Fresh oils, but the slow shipping felt avoidable"
The oils tasted fresh and really good, so no complaints there. I just wish the delivery had been quicker, the delay felt a bit avoidable.
hello_gwendolyn055
May 25, 2026
"I ordered from Cave Creek Olive Oil i..."
I ordered from Cave Creek Olive Oil i thought the prices were fair for what you get. I’ve defintely paid more before for olive oil that didn’t taste nearly as good.
Shipping was totally fine and everything showed up packed really well, no leaks or anything weird. The bottle sizes were decent too, not those tiny ones that feel like they’re gone after a few uses.
Overall I’m happy with it for the money. It tastes fresh and I’ll probaly order again once I run out.
"Good products, but shipping felt a little unpredictable"
I do like the stuff from Cave Creek Olive Oil, so I’m not unhappy with the actual products. My order did arrive and everything was in good shape, which I appreciated. But the delivery part was kind of hit or miss. It showed up later than I thought it would, and the tracking barely updated, so I wasn’t really sure what was going on. Not saying it’s a scam, but the lack of updates made me a little uneasy while I was waiting. I’d probably order again, just not if I needed it quickly
michael_Tennant75
May 25, 2026
"Ordering felt more annoying than it needed to"
I was just trying to order a couple of bottles online, but the site made it feel like more work than it should’ve been. Pages were loading slowly for me, and I had to click around way too much just to find basic product details.
Checkout was kind of confusing too. I kept wondering if my cart had actually updated correctly, and you expect shipping info to be easy to spot, but it really wasn’t.
The order did eventually go through, so it wasn’t a total disaster. Still, the whole thing felt a bit frustrating and not very smooth.
"Decent gift, but the options felt a bit limited"
I bought a few bottles as a birthday gift, and they seemed to go over well. The website was straightforward enough, and I did like that the flavors were a little more interesting than the usual boring gift basket stuff. The packaging looked nice too. That said, I was kind of disappointed by the lack of simple gift set options. It worked out fine in the end, but I probably would’ve been more excited about it if there were more easy, ready-to-go choices.
"I guess I’m buying it again"
I ordered it once just to try it, not really expecting much, but I have to admit the olive oil is good. Shipping was fine, not exactly fast, but not a big deal either. I liked it enough that, yeah, I’m coming back for another bottle.
"This balsamic was decent overall. The flavor..."
This balsamic was decent overall. The flavor was nice, kind of mellow and pleasant, but I guess I was expecting something a little thicker and richer, especially for the price. I kept thinking it would be great on a salad or maybe drizzled over tomatoes, though I’ve had others I liked more. Nothing wrong with it, really, it just didn’t make me go back for another taste the way some do. Shipping was fine too, no issues there
jenette.Spurling
April 26, 2026
"Nice place, but I hoped for more local character"
The place looks nice and was perfectly fine, but it didn’t feel very local to me. I always think it’s only fair to highlight the community and give visitors a real sense of the area, so I was a little disappointed it felt more generic than I expected.
ChristinaCooper
April 14, 2026
"Really Like how Clear everything Is"
I ordered from Cave Creek Olive Oil i really appreciated how easy the ingredients were to find and read. No digging around or Guessing what’s actually in the bottles, which is a big deal for me. The labels and the site both felt simple, clear, and straight to the point. It definitely makes me feel better about ordering from them again.
amanda1981
April 13, 2026
"I’ve been using this olive oil mostly..."
I’ve been using this olive oil mostly on salads and with bread, and it’s been really nice. It has a fresh, clean taste and feels smooth without that harsh bitterness some olive oils can have. It’s not overly fancy or anything, but the quality seems solid and I’m happy with it overall. I’d buy it again
Charity_barron97
March 30, 2026
"Pretty happy with my order, honestly"
I ordered a couple of olive oils and wasn’t totally sure what to expect, but everything arrived well packed and in good shape. The flavors were actually better than what I usually grab at the grocery store, which surprised me a bit. The website was easy enough to use too. I’ll probably order again, assuming the next batch is just as good.
stuart_Jenkins03
March 30, 2026
"The return itself was fine. Straightforward. But..."
The return itself was fine. Straightforward. But the refund took longer than I expected. Not terrible, just a bit slow.
ClairKillion_40
March 17, 2026
"Popped into the shop i was immediately impressed..."
Popped into the shop i was immediately impressed. The staff were really friendly, gave us a nice welcome, and helped us out without hovering or being pushy at all.
richard1989
March 05, 2026
"Recommendations felt a bit careless"
I tried the oils they suggested, but they really didn’t work for me. it felt a little irresponsible to recommend them like they were a sure thing when they clearly weren’t a good fit.
Tom.johnson
March 03, 2026
"Really disappointed with the packaging"
The packaging was frustrating. The box showed up kind of crushed, and the bottle was already leaking when I opened it. Not exactly what you want to deal with after waiting for an order to arrive.
david1974
February 25, 2026
"Good products, but customer service took a while"
I’ve bought from them before and like the products, but this time the support side was frustrating. I emailed about my order earlier in the week and didn’t hear back until a few days later. By the time they replied, it felt a bit rushed and not super helpful. It wasn’t a terrible experience, but after waiting that long, I expected a little more.
geraldinewillis2076
February 21, 2026
"Got the wrong bottle in my order"
I ordered a couple of bottles, and one of them wasn’t the one I actually picked. The packing slip had the correct item listed, but the bottle in the box was something else. Shipping was fine, but I was disappointed with the mix-up, especially since I try to be careful about what I spend and don’t want to pay for something I didn’t choose. I emailed them, and it did get sorted out eventually, but it took a little longer than I would’ve liked
martha1981
February 20, 2026
"First thing I noticed: the selection is different"
My first impression was that this place has stuff I genuinely haven’t seen anywhere else. The picks feel really unique, and it made browsing way more fun than I expected.
luella_Flood72
February 16, 2026
"Easy to get around"
Easy. The site was simple to use, and I found what I needed quickly. Checkout was smooth too. Nice. The only thing I noticed was that a few pages loaded a little slower than I expected.
hello_stanley552
February 12, 2026
"Honestly, it tastes homemade to me"
I just tried this recently, so maybe I’m still a little impressed by that first taste, but it really does come close to homemade. The olive flavor tastes real and fresh, not like some fake or overly processed version